Gluten-Free Cincinnati Chili Four-Way – A Healthier, Protein-Packed Twist

Cincinnati chili isn’t your average bowl of chili—it’s something entirely its own. Unlike the Texas-style kind served in a bowl, Cincinnati chili is a spiced meat sauce traditionally served over spaghetti and topped with shredded cheddar cheese. It’s a beloved Midwestern comfort food, and today, I’m sharing my healthier, Gluten-Free Cincinnati Chili Four-Way that stays true to the flavor while being a bit more nourishing.

Jump to Recipe

The Unique Origins of Cincinnati Chili

Cincinnati chili has a fascinating history. It was created in the 1920s by Macedonian immigrants, most notably Tom and John Kiradjieff, who adapted Mediterranean spices to appeal to American palates. Their version of chili—flavored with warm spices like cinnamon, cloves, and allspice—was first served over spaghetti in their restaurant, Empress Chili. Over time, the “ways” were born:

• Two-Way: Chili + spaghetti
• Three-Way: Chili + spaghetti + cheese
• Four- and Five-way variations include onions and/or beans

My Gluten-Free Take on a Classic

I’ve always loved the unique flavor of Cincinnati chili, but I wanted to make it a little lighter and completely gluten-free—without losing that classic richness.

Here’s what makes my version special:

Ground turkey: A leaner protein added to the beef keeps the hearty chili flavor while lowering saturated fat.

Rice vermicelli noodles: A gluten-free alternative to spaghetti that holds up beautifully under the rich chili sauce.

Beans: Not traditional in a three-way, but I added them to boost the protein and make the dish more filling and nutritious.

Cheddar & Mozzarella cheese: A generous sprinkle of sharp cheddar melts into the chili, and the mozzaarella creates the signature creamy finish.

Spices That Set It Apart

What truly makes Cincinnati chili unique is its warm spice blend. Unlike other chilis that rely on heat, this one brings subtle sweetness and complexity. Think:

• Cinnamon
• Cocoa powder
• Allspice
• Cloves
• A dash of vinegar

This medley gives the chili a slightly sweet, tangy profile that’s both surprising and incredibly comforting.

Quick and Easy to Make

Don’t let the ingredient list scare you—this dish is easy to put together in under thirty minutes, and the leftovers are even better the next day. I was gifted the cans of SKYLINE CHILI (Thank you nephew Zach), so my recipe was even easier to put together. The chili sauce simmers on the stove while you prepare your noodles and toppings. Assemble everything in layers, and you’ve got a dish that feels nostalgic.

A couple of interesting chilis from the blog include:

• ANCHO TURKEY CHILI
• CAJUN CHILI

Why You’ll Love This Version:

Gluten-free and family-friendly

Lower in fat, higher in protein

Comfort food with a twist

Big flavor, minimal effort

If you’re craving something hearty, cozy, and just a little different—this Gluten-Free Cincinnati Four-Way Chili is your answer. It’s a comforting nod to tradition with a midwestern, modern, wholesome upgrade.

The cast of characters

Assembling the chili

The Gluten-Free Cincannati Chili Four-Way plated