This post may contain affiliate links which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through links. I will only recommend products that I have personally used! Learn more on my Private Policy page.
That’s right. You heard me right! Cinnamon Raisin BAGEL Bread Pudding. I was contacted by reps of Bruegger’s Bagels looking for food bloggers to develop creative ideas using Bruegger products. Obviously, the base needs to be a bagel. I believe most of us have seen Chopped on the Food Network? You know the face when they open the box and they either have no idea what the ingredient is or what they are going to do with the ingredients provided. That was my first reaction to the request. That momentary blank space in my thought process was not going to stop me.
Cinnamon Raisin BAGEL Bread Pudding
After focusing on the fact that I was working with bread, I thought that bagels would be a great vehicle for bread pudding. When one makes bread pudding, stale bread is good. So the firmness of the bagel is a good thing. I actually decided to make 2 different bread puddings. I wanted to take advantage of the different bagel types. So the cinnamon raisin naturally lent itself to more of a breakfast type adaptation. The wheat and plain bagels enabled me to go down a more traditional path.
I do not know when the last time you went into a Bruegger’s Bagel shop. For me, it has been a while because there is not a store to close to me. I was surprised to find a menu that included a breakfast sandwich called a Mediterranean Sunrise – which includes and egg, Genoa salami, red peppers, cucumbers and feta cheese. They also had a lunch sandwich called the Greek Goddess that had raosted turkey, feta, fresh tomatoes, cucumbers arugula on a butter-toasted potato bread and topped with a champagne vinaigrette. They have all kinds of coffee including a Coconut Iced Coffee – giving you a little taste of the Caribbean. Simply stated, Bruegger’s is not just a bagel store!
Bruegger’s Storefront
Bagel Counter
The cast of characters.
Ingredients
The cinnamon raisin bagels broken up and added to the bowl.
Bagel Broken Up in Bowl
Milk added to the bagels, and then, the cream cheese.
Milk Added
Cream Cheese Added
The egg and sugar mixture added followed by the cinnamon and more cream cheese.
Egg Mixture & Cinnamon
Cream Cheese Added to Final Mixture
The mixture placed in the baking dish.
Put into the Baking Dish
The Cinnamon Raisin Bagel Bread Pudding taking out of the oven.
Cinnamon Raisin BAGEL Bread Pudding after Baking
The Cinnamon Raisin Bagel Bread Pudding Plated.
Cinnamon Raisin BAGEL Bread Pudding Plated
- 4 Bruegger's Cinnamon Raisin Bagels
- 2 tbsp butter, softenened
- 3 medium eggs, beaten
- 4 ounces cream cheese, softened
- 1 qt whole milk
- 2 tbsp vanilla extract
- 2 cups sugar
- 1/2 cup (Good) Maple Syrup
- 2 tablespoons dark brown sugar
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 2 tablespoons whole milk
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
- Butter a baking dish and set aside.
- Break the bagels and drop into a bowl. Just pull it apart with your hands.
- Add the milk a little at a time over the bread.
- Mix it with you hands and make sure the bread absorbs the milk.
- In a small bowl, combine the eggs and the sugar using a whisk.
- Add in the cream cheese.
- Pour in the vanilla extract. Then pour over the bread.
- Pour the bread pudding into the buttered dish, spreading it evenly in the dish.
- Place the dish in a shallow roasting pan filling the pan with boiling water 1″ up the side of the casserole dish.
- Place in the oven and bake 50 – 60 minutes. You will know it is done when a knife goes in and comes out clean.
- Combine all ingredients in a sauce pan.
- Bring to a boil and reduce to a simmer.
- Serve and enjoy!
Bread pudding along side rice pudding are probably the two most defining memories of desserts when I was growing up in the UK and whilst I don’t really have a sweet tooth when I want a dash of nostalgia it is usually one of the two. The idea of bagels in this is wonderful, sounds great!
Thx so much Brian. Glad it brought back some memories.
How clever! I love using up leftover bagels this way. I’m always grabbing bags of their day old bagels and can’t wait to try this!
Now you have the perfect use for day old bagels.
Please, be my neighbor. Seriously.
You are so funny. I will only be your neighbor if we both cook and share our recipes!
What a brilliant idea!
Thx so much Jeff.
So much to love about this bread pudding! I will have to try it soon!
So much Love. I like that. And I thought that was reserved for your kids? LOL
Oh wow! I never would have thought to use bagels in a bread pudding but I am loving the sound of these bagels and this recipe!! What a great treat
I had not thought of it before either but bagels were perfect for this recipe.
I just adore cinnamon raisin bagels so I can imagine this bread pudding is phenomenal! Would never have thought to use bagels, good call:-)
Thank you very much Camilla.
Hmm cinnamon and raisins are always winner, fantastic!
They are a good combo!
Ooh what a great idea! I love using different breads in my bread and butter pudding – I’ve used brioche a few times, but never bagels! Sounds yum.
A bread pudding lends itself to different ideas. Also very easy to use an almond milk or soy milk to make it vegan.
What a great idea to use bagels! I wish we had bagel places like this here in the UK.
Got to be somewhere you can go to find a decent bagel?
Cinnamon raisin bagels are my absolute favourite so this is right up my street!
If they are your favorite bagel then this recipe is right up your alley.
I’m making this pudding for my mom. She’s going to love it. The maple sauce is calling me…
Claudia! Claudia! Claudia! I am the maple syrup call you!
Come to think of it, it makes perfect sense to use bagels in bread pudding. Your version looks delightful.
That is how I felt after I came up with the idea and tried it. It seems so obvious now.
Oh my God Peter – what a great recipe! Holy cow, I love that you added cream cheese! I would eat a huge portion of this.
I would love to share a huge portion with you.
What a fantastic recipe, I have to try it! Nettie
Thank you very much Nettie.
I just love Brueger’s Bagels and I appreciate the reminder of all of their great menu items! Your recipe for bread pudding looks just scrumptious – can’t wait to give this one a try!
Thx so much Debra!